Hey HR Professionals, I need some advice. We have a newer supervisor in the customer service department who's been having trouble with her teaching methods. All her team members have complained that her approach is far from the positive learning environment we aim for. She's been disciplining and using a condescending tone in front of everyone.
She’s especially hard on one new female employee, who's only been with us for a few weeks and is still learning. Instead of fostering a positive learning environment, she’s been treating this new employee disrespectfully, making her feel dumb and unintelligent. This behavior has been confirmed by multiple team members.
Some specific instances include yelling at her in front of everyone, embarrassing her, and treating her like a toddler. When the new employee shares ideas in meetings, the supervisor shuts her down. The team also says she's micromanaging them. As a result, none of them respect her.
Normally, we would coach and develop the supervisor, but given the risk of employees leaving because of her behavior, I'm wondering if we should consider pulling her from the position. We usually try to coach and mentor first, but this seems urgent.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated! 🙏