Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
What is this?
Less
More

Memberships

CFD Dose

Public • 1k • $1/m

4 contributions to CFD Dose
Is the finite difference method necessary for cfd?
Hello everybody first post here, I am learning cfd through a self-learning approach since my university did not offer an undergrad cfd course. I have just finished learning my first cfd course based on FDM from YouTube provided by the university of Boston and instructed by prof Lorena barba. And as a cfd novice I am curious about one thing. I have noticed that most introduction courses to cfd are based on FDM, but I wonder why is that? why aren't introduction cfd courses based on FVM as I guess it can do more(works with structured and unstructured meshes,results in a conservative form of the numerical schemes and many other benefits that I am not aware of).
3
1
New comment Apr 24
6 likes • Apr 24
Finite difference methods still form the basis of finite volume methods. Within an FVM implementation, you use finite differences to approximate things like gradients of point-valued functions. The difference is that then FVM uses those FDM approximations and integrates them on surfaces or volumes which gives nice properties like conservation and geometric flexibility. Alternatively you can use Green-Gauss (an integral form) to compute gradients, and that's not really FDM. FDM methods are all about approximating derivatives, which happens everywhere, so it's a proper place to start an intro CFD course. (My first CFD course did go into FVM, many do.)
Live CFD Projects to gain Exp
Dear all, I am an undergraduate student from India. I have general proficiency in CFD however I want to learn more, be able to write an entire CFD Code suitable for my applications and become more capable in the same. Thus, I am looking for any internships/live projects in CFD which I can join to get a hands-on experience on the same. Would be great if i could get some suggestions from you all. Thank you!!
10
15
New comment Apr 15
2 likes • Apr 13
@Anirudh Diwakar @Ahmed Zaid @Walid Badawy @Michał Murzyn an overview here
2 likes • Apr 13
@Anirudh Diwakar So 100% of the code is present in the text writeup and the accompanying github repository. You can literally just download and build the final project, or turn your brain off and copy-paste all the code (learning nothing in the process). It's something I've found difficult in the writing process and I'm curious how a reader like yourself would experience it, hence seeking feedback before I release it all publicly. So in theory you could have zero C++ experience at all, but I've also shown this to seasoned C++ experts in the field who still learn something from the architecture. I'll figure out how to do this; either I'll give you access to the currently-private repository or just email early drafts of the HTML docs.
Introduce yourself to the group 👇
Hi everybody! Happy to have you all here and very excited to kick-start a long journey of mentorship and growth with all of you. To help get to know each other and break the shyness, take a moment to introduce yourself below and let others know what you're currently working on (CFD or in general). ** Please make sure you have carefully read this post and participated in this poll [takes 5 seconds] Let's go!
42
213
New comment Sep 17
Introduce yourself to the group 👇
6 likes • Apr 13
I'm just here because I was curious how it works, but I'm gainfully employed :) NASA now, formerly Siemens and Cadence. Iowa State undergrad, Princeton PhD. Primarily solver development in FV and DG, and HPC solver architecture.
1 like • Apr 13
@Mohamed Sayed well I started in computer science at Iowa state as an undergrad for no reason other than I was "good with computers" but that didn't really work out. Found aerospace engineering and loved how diverse the curriculum was. I had never heard of CFD at the time. Eventually was taking an aerodynamics course with Ganesh rajagopalan and he found out I could do some c++, and he asked me to work for his small rotorcraft company doing development. Decided to stay for an MS with him starting 2008, he let me pick any topic I wanted, so I developed GPU CFD code in the early days. Enjoyed the field and wanted more, so I found myself starting a PhD at Princeton. Initially worked on structured multi block FV solvers with some wind energy applications. Eventually wrote a fairly advanced high order DG code for the bulk of my thesis. A job opportunity came up at Siemens / former CD adapco, as a physics developer for STAR-CCM+ where I developed some key stuff and also started the GPU port. Was there for 5 years, then got an opportunity at Cadence during their acquisitions of CFD companies. Worked on solvers there for 2 years til an opportunity came up in the computational aerosciences branch at NASA Langley and I've been there for 6 months now working on their cfd codes. Tldr wrote a ridiculous amount of CFD code for 15+ years and got decent at it :)
Question/Discussion: How much does it matter which university you study at?
Hey everyone. So in today's virtual coffee, I mentioned that I'm looking to pursue a MSc degree, but the options for fundings/programs are not always that easily available, given one's personal background and resume, you might be needing to go for whatever chance that gets you closer. From your experience, how much does the ranking/reputation of a university or the country you're studying at matter? *Specifically Europe.* And how does that affect one's chance of getting into industry or doing PhD after MSc?
5
17
New comment Apr 21
1 like • Apr 13
I can't speak to Europe, but I would say as long as it's a reputable university, you won't be passed over and you'll be judged on your work/skills. Although I have seen some UK postdoc listings which specified they wanted phds from top universities, which I found a little odd. That said, you might find better resources at "better" universities.
1-4 of 4
Mark Lohry
3
31points to level up
@mark-lohry-7391
NASA Langley computational aerosciences, former Siemens STAR-CCM+ dev, former Cadence CFD dev

Active 201d ago
Joined Apr 12, 2024
powered by